Weber Griddle Insert vs Blackstone – Which one to Buy

When it comes to outdoor cooking, having the right griddle can elevate your culinary experiences to new heights. Both Weber and Blackstone are well-known brands that offer griddle inserts, each with its own unique features and benefits. So, Weber Griddle Insert vs Blackstone, which one is better?

Weber Griddle Insert vs Blackstone Comparison

	Weber Griddle Insert	Blackstone
Compatibility	Weber griddle inserts are designed to fit specific Weber gas grills, essentially converting your grill into a griddle. This means you need to own a compatible Weber grill to use the griddle insert.	Unlike the Weber griddle insert, Blackstone griddles are standalone units. They come with their own legs or stands, making them portable and easy to use anywhere outdoors.
Versatility	While the primary purpose of the griddle insert is to provide a flat cooking surface, you can still use one side of your grill as a griddle while using the other side as a regular grill, adding versatility to your outdoor cooking options.	Blackstone offers a wide range of griddle models with different features, such as foldable legs for portability, integrated side tables, and even ones with built-in burners.
Cooking area	Weber griddle inserts are typically made of porcelain-enameled cast iron, which provides excellent heat retention and even heat distribution. This material helps in achieving consistent cooking results.	Blackstone griddles come in various sizes, offering a larger cooking surface compared to most Weber grill inserts. This is advantageous if you need to cook for a large group of people regularly.

Advantages of Weber Griddle Insert

The Weber griddle insert offers several advantages for outdoor cooking enthusiasts who already own a compatible Weber gas grill. Here are some of the key benefits:

Also Read>> Napoleon Prestige vs Weber Genesis – Which one is the Best?

Compatibility

The Weber griddle insert is specifically designed to fit certain models of Weber gas grills. If you already own one of these grills, the griddle insert allows you to convert your grill into a versatile griddle without the need for an additional standalone unit.

High-Quality Construction

Weber is renowned for its durable and well-crafted products. The griddle insert is typically made of porcelain-enameled cast iron, which ensures excellent heat retention and even heat distribution across the cooking surface.

Even Cooking

The cast iron construction of the griddle insert helps to distribute heat evenly, which is essential for achieving consistent and uniform cooking results. This ensures that your food cooks thoroughly without any hotspots.

Versatility

While the primary purpose of the griddle insert is to provide a flat cooking surface, you can still use one side of your grill as a griddle while using the other side as a regular grill. This adds versatility to your outdoor cooking options, allowing you to prepare a variety of dishes at once.

No Need for Extra Space

Unlike standalone griddles, the Weber griddle insert do not require additional storage space. You can easily keep it with your Weber grill, making it a space-saving solution for expanding your cooking capabilities.

Easy to Clean

Weber griddle inserts are designed for easy cleaning. The porcelain-enameled surface is relatively non-stick, which simplifies the cleaning process after cooking.

Brand Reputation

Weber is a well-established and trusted brand in the outdoor cooking industry. Choosing a Weber griddle insert means you can rely on the brand’s reputation for quality and customer support.

Accessories and Add-ons

Weber often offers various accessories and add-ons for their griddle inserts, such as a lid that allows you to turn the griddle into an oven-like cooking space. This expands the cooking possibilities even further.

Integrated Design

The griddle insert fits seamlessly into your Weber grill, maintaining the overall appearance and design of your grill setup.

Advantages of Blackstone

Blackstone griddles offer several advantages that have contributed to their popularity among outdoor cooking enthusiasts. Here are some of the key advantages of Blackstone griddles:

Large Cooking Surface

Blackstone griddles typically come with a large, flat cooking surface, providing ample space to cook for a large group of people or prepare multiple dishes simultaneously.

Even Heat Distribution

The thick cold-rolled steel construction of the griddle surface ensures even heat distribution, which is essential for achieving consistent cooking results across the entire cooking area.

Independent Heat Zones

Many Blackstone griddles feature multiple independently controlled heat zones. This allows you to adjust the temperature in different areas of the griddle, providing greater versatility for cooking various types of food at once.

Versatility

Blackstone griddles are incredibly versatile and can be used to cook a wide variety of foods, from breakfast items like pancakes and eggs to lunch and dinner options like burgers, steaks, vegetables, and more.

Outdoor Portability

Blackstone griddles are designed for outdoor use and come with their own legs or folding stands, making them highly portable. You can easily take them to camping trips, tailgating events, picnics, or use them in your backyard.

Easy Setup and Ignition

Setting up a Blackstone griddle is generally quick and straightforward. Many models come with built-in ignition systems, eliminating the need for matches or lighters.

Easy to Clean

Blackstone griddles are designed for easy cleaning. They often have a removable grease trap or grease management system, making cleanup after cooking a breeze.

Durable Construction

The griddles are built with sturdy materials that can withstand outdoor use. The cold-rolled steel cooking surface ensures durability and excellent heat retention.

Affordable

Blackstone griddles offer a cost-effective solution for expanding your outdoor cooking options. They are often more affordable than purchasing a separate grill and griddle.

Accessories and Add-ons

Blackstone offers a range of accessories that enhance the griddle’s functionality, such as griddle covers, spatulas, and grill boxes. These accessories allow you to customize your griddle to suit your specific cooking needs.

Restaurant-Quality Cooking

With a Blackstone griddle, you can achieve restaurant-quality cooking results right in your backyard. The high heat and even cooking surface allow you to sear and cook food to perfection.

Also Read>> Best Rotisserie for Weber Kettle – Do you Need One?

What is the difference between Blackstone and griddle on Weber?

Blackstone and griddle on Weber refer to different types of outdoor cooking equipment. Blackstone specializes in standalone griddles with a large, flat cooking surface, often equipped with independent heat zones for versatile outdoor cooking. These griddles are portable and come with their own legs or stands.

On the other hand, “griddle” on Weber refers to a griddle insert designed to fit certain Weber gas grills, converting the grill into a griddle. It offers even heat distribution and versatility for cooking a variety of foods. The main difference lies in their design, portability, and compatibility with Weber grills.

What makes Blackstone griddle different?

Blackstone griddles stand out for several reasons. Firstly, they are standalone units with a spacious and flat cooking surface made of thick cold-rolled steel, ensuring even heat distribution for consistent cooking results.

Many models feature multiple independent heat zones, allowing for versatile cooking options. Their portability makes them ideal for outdoor use, and they come with their own legs or folding stands for easy setup.

Also Read>> Weber Spirit II E-310 Gas Grill Review– Everything You Need to Know

Further, Blackstone griddles are known for their durability, restaurant-quality cooking capabilities, and affordability compared to purchasing separate grill and griddle units. These features, combined with a wide range of available accessories, make Blackstone griddles a popular choice among outdoor cooking enthusiasts.

How do you use a Weber griddle insert?

Using a Weber griddle insert is relatively straightforward. Here’s a general guide on how to use it:

• Ensure compatibility: Make sure the griddle insert is designed to fit your specific Weber gas grill model.
• Preheat: Preheat your grill with the griddle insert in place. Follow the recommended preheating temperature for the best cooking results.
• Oil the griddle: Before cooking, lightly coat the griddle surface with cooking oil to prevent sticking.
• Cook: Place the food on the preheated griddle and cook as you would on a regular griddle. Use the grill’s temperature controls to achieve the desired heat.
• Clean: After cooking, allow the griddle to cool slightly, then clean it with a brush or spatula. Avoid using harsh cleaning agents to preserve the griddle’s coating.

What is the purpose of a griddle on a grill?

The purpose of a griddle on a grill is to provide a flat and even cooking surface for preparing a wide variety of foods. Unlike traditional grill grates with gaps, a griddle offers a smooth, non-stick surface that allows you to cook delicate items like eggs, pancakes, and vegetables without them falling through the gaps.

It also provides an ideal surface for cooking foods that require even heat distribution, such as meats and fish. Griddles on grills are versatile, allowing you to expand your outdoor cooking options and achieve restaurant-quality results right in your backyard.

What is the downside of a Blackstone griddle?

While Blackstone griddles have many advantages, there are some downsides to consider. One significant drawback is their size and weight, which can make them less portable compared to smaller camping grills.

Additionally, the large cooking surface might not be suitable for individuals or small families with limited cooking needs. Some users also find that the griddle’s seasoning process requires regular maintenance and can be time-consuming.

Furthermore, the absence of a traditional grill grate means you won’t get the characteristic grill marks on your food. Lastly, depending on the model, Blackstone griddles may lack certain advanced features found in high-end outdoor cooking appliances.

Conclusion

The decision between the Weber Griddle Insert and Blackstone griddle comes down to your specific grilling needs and preferences.

If you already own a Weber gas grill and desire to expand its cooking versatility, the Weber Griddle Insert is an excellent choice. It seamlessly converts your grill into a griddle station, providing convenience and familiarity.

On the other hand, if you prefer a standalone griddle with more cooking space and portability, the Blackstone griddle is the better option. Its independent design offers a larger cooking surface and flexibility for outdoor cooking adventures.

Consider factors like grill compatibility, versatility, portability, and budget to make an informed decision. Both options are reputable and will undoubtedly enhance your outdoor cooking experience. Happy grilling!